Wednesday, October 10, 2007
Myth Bustin' Columbus....13 Style
This past Monday was our annual remembrance of Christopher Columbus. For his name to be so recognizable most people know very little about him and there is a very likely chance that what they do know is actually false. Here are a few of the more common myths and facts regarding Christopher Columbus.1. Christopher Columbus was Spanish. Well, it would make sense since Columbus sailed under the Spanish flag, but the long term story is that Columbus was born in Genoa, Italy. However, there are many other theories that have linked Columbus to a Jewish background, the island of Corsica, and even a Viking background.
2. The main goal for the first voyage was to prove the Earth was round and not flat. This is a false statement. By 1492, most of the educated people in Europe understood the Earth was a sphere. However, there was a great debate regarding just how big the planet really was. Even Columbus had to readjust his views after completing that first voyage.
3. The crews on board the Nina, the Pinta, and the Santa Maria were filled with cut-throat criminals. While records indicate that amnesty would be granted to those who would undertake the voyage very few criminals applied for a pardon.
4. The only reason Isabella and Ferdinand of Spain agreed to fund the journey is Columbus stated he would spread Christianity to those he encountered. While there are iconic paintings of Columbus and his men landing in the New World with a priest in tow there were no clergymen on the first journey. By the second journey five priests had managed to tag along. In the picture above the priest is seen clutching the Bible behind the standard.
5. Columbus is buried in Santo Domingo. This is not necessarily so. Many records conflict this by stating his remains were moved. Maybe he is in several locations. The primary resting spot is the Cathedral of Seville in Spain. The tomb is pictured below. Santa Domingo, Genoa, and even Cuba are also mentioned in various sources.
6. Columbus discovered North America. Not quite. He was searching for a faster route to the Orient than the overland Silk Road. His theory was the Orient could be reached from Europe by sailing west. He landed in the Caribbean Islands and at no time did he ever set foot on the continent of North America. Columbus actually thought he had landed in the Orient and had no clue North or South America even existed.7. Columbus was the first man to reach the New World. This is also false. We have many sources that indicate there were plenty of visits and near visits to North and South America before Columbus such as visits by the Vikings and the Chinese explorer Zheng He. Knowledge regarding these initial visits in no way decreases the importance of the efforts of Columbus. He should be remembered because his voyages inaugurated the first permanent contact between the East and the West.
8. The Spanish monarchy had to sell the crown jewels in order to fund the journey. Actually, it is believed Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand cut a deal with the city of Palos so that the citizens there could replay a debt to the crown. The debt covered the cost of two of the ships. There was also some Italian funds that backed the trip as well.
9. I learned in high school Columbus died from syphillis. Did you? That’s not correct. While he had poor eyesight and gout Columbus did no die of syphillis. The disease was in Europe after 1492, but Columbus did not have it.
10. Columbus died in prison. This is also false. He actually died on May 20, 1506 in Valladoliad, Spain. At one time he was in chains at the end of his third voyage, but upon landing in Spain a misunderstanding was cleared up and the chains disappeared.
11. Women were never allowed on the voyages, and horses did not arrive in the New World until the conquistadors. Actually women did travel with Columbus on his third voyage. There was one woman for every ten emigrants. Horses, however reached the New World before women. They came over on the second voyage.
12. Many believe Columbus arrived with several hundered men, but that’s not true either. The
ships he used were very tiny compared to today’s standards. They were probably no bigger than a tennis court and were less than 30 feet wide. The Santa Maria had a crew of 40, the Pinta had 26, and the Nina had the smallest crew with 24 men.13. On that first voyage only the Nina and the Pinta returned triumphantly to Spain. This is fact. The Santa Mara was shipwrecked around Christmas in 1492. Thirty-nine members of her crew volunteered to stay behind at La Navidad, a fortress that was built on the northern coast of what is today the island of Haiti. Unfortunately all of these men were killed by natives. They were upset because the Spaniard s had mistreated them
Visit other Thursday Thirteens here.
Labels: Christopher Columbus, History Myths, Thursday Thirteen
21 Comments:
I knew some of this -- only because I live in Columbus, but many things I did not know. My boys will love this.
Very interesting...
I love these history lessons!
How very educational...
Columbus speaks to my imagination! You busted some myths though! ;-)
My TT shares 13 quotes by W.B. Yeats.
Very interesting, thank you. Apart from #1, I didn't know any of that.
This was awesome as always! There was so much that I did not know, or had forgotten. I am going to pass this on!
Thank you for that! We were seriously taught in high school that he 1. discovered America, and 2. died of syphillus, in prison.
:-) Happy TT!
I adore these history lessons.
Thanks for this.
Mine's up--also historically based this week.
I love hitorical TTs. You're always bound to learn something. I actually hadn't heard of all these myths. I like to think when I had history in school those many *cough*cough* years ago, that my teachers actually did a good job. Nowadays with all the teaching to the test teachers have to do, I have no idea what kids are walking away with in terms of knowledge. And thanks for the memory. I have seen the tomb in Sevilla, which yous pictured reminded me that I had been there.
Brilliant. I really appreciated this concise historical summary. I was definitely taught otherwise in school back in the sixties---amazing how much more we know now than then...
This post has been removed by the author.
Enjoyed your list. We just finished reading a book about Columbus, that debunked some of the myths.
He is a fascinating person, there is so much we don't know about him, and he lived during such an exciting period.
Great information. And, while I knew some of it, I learned something new today. Thanks you.
Happy TT!
Thanks for the myth-busting....always a good thing to know the truth!
Happy TT!
oh what a fun blog!!
Amazingly, I hadn't heard most of these myths. But I didn't know much of anything about Columbus.
Blessings,
Karla
Great, great post! Love it! I hate how history gets distorted over the years, sometimes on purpose.
I have two TT's up! http://qtpies7-goodstuff.blogspot.com/2007/10/thursday-thirteen-1-win-wii.html and
http://qtpies7.blogspot.com/2007/10/thursday-thirteen-e-proverbs.html.
Loved this, very educational! Happy TT!
Thanks for interesting info!
Mandy
That was an interesting read, thankyou
I didn't even pretend to know much of what you wrote here! I appreciate your dredging up this material, digesting it for us, and putting it in readable form. Have you ever considered publishing a Reader's Digest of History? Among those who don't like slogging through daunting tomes, I'm sure there'd be a market!
Post a Comment
<< Home