Tuesday, May 06, 2008
Historical Triage
If you are a history teacher then you probably already know what I mean by historical triage. The history of America, the history of the world, the history of Georgia, and even the history of a button can be a very vast area to cover. We simply can’t do it all in the amount of time we are given. Sometimes, however, I wish I had more time to share everything I would like to with students.

That is often impossible, however, because as the teacher I’m given a set of standards with the directive of making sure those items are taught. If I deviate from “the plan” then students aren’t prepared for the next set of standards for higher grade levels, and they aren’t prepared for the state assessment. However, as a passionate history teacher I know that more information can help students see a bigger picture, more information can help students connect to information already learned, and more information can help motivate students to dig further. It is quite a conundrum though. Out of all of the possible tibits of “extra” history, which ones do I attempt to include and which ones do I sacrifice for another day, another time, or even for another teacher to cover? It’s all a matter of triage.

For example, in the fifth grade one teaching standard states, the student will describe the importance of key people, events, and developments between 1950-1975. Now that standard covers twenty-five years of history jam packed with people, events, and developments. How do I know what Georgia considers important?

Luckily elements are given with each standard to serve as a guidebook when planning lessons, so that I know how specific I should get. Element (a.) states the student should be able to discuss the importance of the Vietnam War, and (b.) the student should know something about Justice Thurgood Marshall. This leads me to the conclusion that President Johnson will need to be introduced to students along with his two-front war….the war in Vietnam and the domestic war against racial inequality, poverty, and many other social ills more commonly known as The Great Society simply because President Johnson greatly increased our involvement in Vietnam and he also appointed Marshall to the Supreme Court.

Sadly, this could mean much of the interesting life of LBJ could be triaged and left on my planning room floor. I believe sharing President Johnson’s social programs with students is key to understanding the entire decade of the sixties and on towards present day. A look at the Great Society also ties in with previous studies such as the War Between the States, Reconstruction, the resurrgence of the Ku Klux Klan, etc., but I have to be reasonable. I cannot cover everything.

One way I attempt to share more of LBJ with my students is with a discovery activity I have devised. After a few days spent in the jungles of Vietnam I turn students’ attention to the Johnson’s domestic programs and his wish to improve American society. We discuss how the Great Society was an effort to eliminate poverty, reverse racial injustice, improve education, clean up urban blight, and protect the environment. We discuss how Johnson had an incredible amount of money flooding into Asia as well as gushing into Great Society programs.

One morning students arrive to see a question I’ve written on the board in large letters, “What would make President Johnson so passionate about improving American society?”

With that question in mind, students move into groups armed with copies of one particular resource covering President Johnson’s early life. The resources stop at the point he became a politician. Every group member has their own copy, but each group has a different source. Students are instructed to keep the question on the board in mind, and I ask them to read and analyze the source. Their job is to pull out facts about Johnson that might possible answer the question on the board. For some class groups we might spend a moment or two breaking down the question to make sure students are clear regarding what they are looking for.

I love activities like this because I am allowing the student to discover the information. They love to tell me something I might not know, and as the year progresses they become very competitive with one another in an attempt to learn something new. After a few minutes we gather again, and I ask each group to share one thing they learned. As they share I begin to make a master list on the board underneath our focus question.

One group tells me the Johnson family lived in a very small home with no electricity and no plumbing. Many are amazed by this and I tell them that even as close as fifty years ago there were homes in our own community that still had outhouses. Another group shares that the Johnson’s father was a state legislator, but the family was poor as the father tried to make a living as a farmer and a cattle speculator. Someone on the other side of the room begins to wave their arm frantically. I call on Mr. Wavy Hand and he excitedly shares, “It wasn’t just his father who was a lawmaker. His grandfather was too!”

I say, “Hmmmm…..” as I begin to write that fact on the board and call on the next group. In a rush one young lady advises President Johnson was born in 1908 and his father’s name was Sam Ealy Johnson. His mother’s name was Rebekah Baines Johnson.”

Several students emit a chorus of “Ohhhhhhh!” as they now know where the “Baines” came from in President Johnson’s name. I notice one group seems to be about ready to bust with their tidbit from Johnson’s early life. I go ahead and call on them to show us how intelligent they are. Very Loud Young Man lets out a sigh of relief and states, “I thought someone else would tell you before we could.”

I say, “What? What it is?”

A girl in the group says, “Oh, EHT. This is just soooooo good. You’re going to like this.”

I put my hand on my hip and sigh as I say, “Well……..”

Very Loud Young Man finally explodes by saying, “Johnson grew up near Johnson City, Texas. Johnson City was named for his ancestors who helped settle the area. One of them was named James Polk Johnson. He went to Texas after the War Between the States and….HE WAS FROM GEORGIA!.”

There are several “ohs” and “ahs” around the room including my own, “Really? That’s so neat. Let’s put a star by that fact because if you are like me we will want to know more about Mr. Johnson from Georgia.”

A voice from the back of the room mimics what I often say during class, “Yes, let’s save that for further research.” I smile. I don’t repeat things over and over merely because I like to hear my voice.

We continue on with the facts. As a group we discover President Johnson was talkative in school and was described as awkward. Several students related to this while others related to the fact that even though he probably lived very simply his classmates elected him as president of his eleventh grade class. Another group found a quotation of President Johnson’s where he said, “Poverty was so common we didn’t know it had a name.” We discuss the meaning of the President’s remark and moved on to more facts.

He had four siblings. Someone remarked his house was probably crowded. Another quipped, “Well, he didn’t have his own room. That’s for sure.”

Another group discovered Johnson’s mother’s grandfather had been George Washington Baines. He was a Baptist clergyman and was President of Baylor University. I let student groups discuss this for a minute after wondering outloud why the Johnson family was so poor if they have a university president in their background. Students arrive at all sorts of reasons such as crop failures. and maybe the rest of the family never had the same amount of education for some reason. Someone else remarked that perhaps President Johnson’s mother’s family was better off than his father’s.

We also discover Johnson worked his way through college at Southwest Texas State Teacher’s College. The next group, however, correct my factoid on the board by stating their resource said the college is known as Texas State University---San Marcos today.

Finally, we discovered that for one year before he left for Washington, President Johnson taught school. Oh my, he was a school teacher! He taught at the Welhausen School. His students were almost entirely Mexican and were from very simple circumstances.

Through this activity students learn that politicians are often passionate regarding certain issues because of their past experiences. Now that students understand President Johnson’s zeal in wanting Great Society programs, they are ready to examine and analyze the various components of the various social programs proposed during the late 60s.

This post also appears at American Presidents.

Labels: , ,


  EHT posted at Tuesday, May 06, 2008  
  5 comments



5 Comments:
At 4:29 PM, OpenID fruitfulwords said...

I didn't know most of those facts. Very interesting activity and discussion. I wish I had you as a History teacher.

 
At 12:14 AM, Anonymous Robin said...

First, I absolutely agree that it is almost impossible to know what to teach and what to leave out. In Florida History is not part of our standardized test and so anytime students need to be pulled out or 'test' classes need extra time it is SS that gets dropped. This makes it even harder to get everything in...and people wonder why I get grumpy about having to teach everything from prehistory to 20th century American History all in one year :o) Somehow I think you'd understand.
Second, that is a fantastic lesson plan. I agree with the other comment, I want you as MY teacher :)

 
At 12:24 AM, Blogger Mr. Lee said...

This post has been removed by the author.

 
At 12:25 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Amazing! I'm a history lover myself, but pale in comparison to you! I'm a newbie teacher and trying to improve, so I'm hoping you can answer a few questions.

Where do you end up getting your sources, especially primary sources?

How much do you use the textbook? And how do you incorporate it into your lessons?

 
At 8:49 AM, Blogger EHT said...

Thanks everyone for your kind words.

Anonymous, I get primary sources in any manner I can. The National Archives Digital Vault is a great place, and just through online searches.

My students are 9 and 10 years old. They are transitioning from learning to read to reading to learn. I use the textbook, but not exclusively. It's important for kids to learn how to use the text, but it is also important that they realize it is not the only source for learning history.

My lessons take the content presented in two to three text lessons and combine them into a larger lesson. I might present the info in an informal discussion using a powerpoint rich with images, maps I draw on the board...generally I simply tell the story. This might be followed by activities where students record some notes and manipulate the content with various activities. Once we look at the text lesson students already have prior knowledge and know the basic "story". They are motivated to read as they discover new information about something they have already been introduced to.

The text should be a prop for teaching....not the only source.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home



About Me








Name:
Elementaryhistoryteacher

You can learn more about me here and by visiting the link below.

My Complete Profile


Recent Posts
  • Pop Quiz: Why is Cinco de Mayo a Big Deal, or Is ...
  • An Apple a Day....
  • America: a Great Nation
  • Professional Development at Its Best
  • Gone For the Weekend...
  • 13 Things About the USS Constitution
  • America: A Great Nation
  • Assessment Methods: Easy For You or Best For Them...
  • Past, Present, Future: Augusta National
  • 13 Things I Found in the Digital Vault of the Nati...

  • Paying the Bills
    Find Crunchless Abs and Relacore reviews


    Archives
  • January 2006
  • February 2006
  • March 2006
  • April 2006
  • May 2006
  • June 2006
  • July 2006
  • August 2006
  • September 2006
  • October 2006
  • November 2006
  • December 2006
  • January 2007
  • February 2007
  • March 2007
  • April 2007
  • May 2007
  • June 2007
  • July 2007
  • August 2007
  • September 2007
  • October 2007
  • November 2007
  • December 2007
  • January 2008
  • February 2008
  • March 2008
  • April 2008
  • May 2008
  • June 2008
  • July 2008
  • August 2008
  • September 2008
  • October 2008
  • November 2008
  • December 2008
  • January 2009
  • February 2009
  • March 2009
  • April 2009
  • May 2009
  • June 2009
  • July 2009
  • August 2009
  • September 2009
  • October 2009
  • November 2009
  • December 2009

  • Creative Commons License
    History Is Elementary by Elementaryhistoryteacher is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License.
    Based on a work at http//historyiselementary.blogspot.com.
    Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at http://historyiselementary.blogspot.com.
    Site Index
    1920s
    1950s
    Abraham Lincoln
    acacademic controversy
    Adam Thoroughgood
    Africa
    Alexander Graham Bell
    America: A Great Nation
    American Presidents
    American Revolution
    Amerigo Vespucci
    anachronisms
    Angel Oak
    Anna Nicole Smith
    Antietam
    Articles of Confederation
    Battle of Saratoga
    Battles
    Beach
    Bendict Arnold
    Benjamin West
    Bible
    Black History Month
    Blog Visits
    Blogging
    blogrolls
    Booker T. Washington
    bulletin boards
    Bunker Hill
    camouflage
    Campo de Cahuenga
    Carnival of Georgia Bloggers
    Challenges
    Changing History
    Charles VI of France
    Charleston
    Checks and Balances
    Cherokee Nation
    Chester A. Arthur
    Christmas
    Christopher Columbus
    Civil Rights
    Civil War
    Civil War Resources
    Classroom Management
    Coit Tower
    colonies
    constitution
    Constitutional Convention
    Cortes
    Critical Thinking
    Cubism
    Cultural changes over time
    Current Events
    Curriculum
    Cynthia McKinney
    D-Day
    Daniel Boone
    Dark Shadows
    Dazzle painting
    Declaration of Independence
    Differentiation
    Discipline
    Doc Holliday
    Dr. Martin Luther King
    Doughface
    Dream Teaching
    Drought
    Dungeness
    Early Colonization
    education carnival
    Education Conferences
    Education Reform
    elections
    Elizabeth Cady Stanton
    Ellen Wilson
    Emancipation Proclamation
    End of the Year
    ESOL
    Exploration
    Explorers
    faith
    Fall Break
    Family History
    Fashion
    First Ladies
    Flag Day
    Flag Etiquette
    Former Students
    Forwarded Email
    Four Freedoms
    Fourth of July
    France
    Francis Fauquier
    Francis Land House
    Franklin D. Roosevelt
    Franklin Pierce
    French and Indian War
    frontier
    fun stuff
    Gathering Data
    Genarlow Wilson
    Geography
    George Washington
    Georgia
    Georgia On My Mind
    Gerald R. Ford
    Gifts of State
    Giovanni Cabato
    Government
    Great Depression
    Harriet Beecher Stowe
    Hawaii
    Henry Cabot Lodge
    Henry Laurens
    Hindu Temples
    Historical Paintings
    history
    History Apathy
    history carnival
    History Myths
    Ike Hoover
    Immigration
    Imperialism
    inauguration
    Interesting Sites
    Inventions
    Iraq
    James Madison
    James Monroe
    John Adams
    John McCain
    John A. Quitman
    John Cabot
    John Trumbull
    Johnny Tremaine
    Jr.
    Kennesaw
    Know Nothings
    Korea
    Labor Day
    Land Family
    Legal Issues
    Lesson Ideas
    Lewis and Clark
    Libyan Sibyl
    Lobie
    Lusitania
    Lyndhurst Mansion
    Lyndon B. Johnson
    Marcus Garvey
    Marine Anthem
    Mary Katherine Goddard
    Massachusetts
    Mendi
    Mexican American War
    Michelangelo
    Mike Christian
    military action
    Millard Fillmore
    Mother
    motivation
    Mulberry Grove
    N.C.Wyeth
    Natchez
    Nathanael Greene
    Native Americans
    NCLB
    New Orleans
    New sites
    New Year
    Norman Rockwell
    Northwest Ordinance
    Oneida Nation
    Online Exhibits
    Operation Paul Bunyan
    Oregon Trail
    Ossabaw Island
    Patriots
    Paul Potts
    Pearl Harbor
    Personal
    plantation life
    Pledge of Allegiance
    political parties
    Polly Cooper
    Pop Culture
    Prayer
    Prince Henry the Navigator
    Problem Posting
    Protocol
    Razzle Dazzle
    Read Alouds
    Reading
    Recognition
    Red Oak
    regions
    Religion
    Resources
    Richard Ameryk
    Roald Dahl
    Robert J. Freeman
    Rockwell Kent
    Royal Families
    Samuel Adams
    Santa Claus
    Savannah
    Saying goodbye to students
    Secretary of State
    Sectionalism
    September 11th
    Seven Wonders
    slavery
    Social Studies
    Society
    Sojourner Truth
    Spain
    Speeches
    Star Spangled Banner
    State Department
    State History
    Statues
    Student Teachers
    Students
    Subscription Information
    Supreme Court
    Swearing in
    teacher assessment
    Teacher Potluck
    Teachers
    Teachers in the News
    Teaching
    Teaching Resources
    Teaching Strategies
    Technology
    terrorism
    Testing
    Texas
    Thanksgiving
    the happy dance
    Theodore Roosevelt
    Thirteen Colonies
    Thomas Jefferson
    Thursday Thirteen
    Tools of the Trade
    Top US Architectural Sites
    traditions
    Trail of Tears
    Travel
    Treaty of Cahuenga
    Trenton
    Trivia
    Turn off the Television Week
    U-Boats
    U.S. Capitol
    Under God
    United Streaming
    Valley Forge
    Veterans Day
    Vicksburg
    Videos
    Vietnam War
    Virginia
    War of 1812
    Warm Springs
    Washington Irving
    Websites
    White House
    William Thornton
    Women
    Woodrow Wilson
    Wordless Wednesday
    World War I
    World War II
    Writing Across the Curriculum

    Credits
    Image from:
    istockphoto

    Powered by:



    Blog Design by:


    Receive My Post in Your Email
    Enter your Email Powered by FeedBlitz
    AddThis Social Bookmark Button AddThis Feed Button Subscribe with Bloglines

    Need to reach me by email?
    historyiselementary[at]mail[dot]com

    Top Rated Postings
    Writing Across the Curriculum Using the American Revolution
    Oh, I Love to Tell the Story
    Sex in the Classroom
    Laying a Foundation in Forty Minutes Flat
    Razzle Dazzle and All That Jazz
    Martin Van Buren: He's So K-E-W-L

    Awards & Honors
    2006 Cliopatria Award nominee for Best New Blog

    First Runner-Up…The Best of Blogs, 2008

    Top 30 EduBlog…August, 2007

    Top 50 EduBlog…June, 2008

    See a few more of my awards and nods here




    Add to Technorati Favorites

    See my post I'm In Love With My Lobie and then click on the square below for more information. BRIEF DESCRIPTION
    History Academics, Topics, and Teachers
    A History Teacher
    A Very Old Place
    A. Lincoln Blog
    AHA Blog
    ahistoricality
    American Presidents Blog
    American Revolution and Founding Era
    Another History Blog
    Bablionia61
    BibliOdyssey
    Blog Them Out of the Stone Age
    Blog4History
    Boston, 1775
    Cardinal Woolsey’s Today in History
    Civil War Memory
    Civil Warriors
    Cliopatria
    Daily Chronicles of the American Civil War
    Damn Interesting
    Dr. History
    Dump Diggers
    Executed Today
    Facing South
    Ghost in the Machine
    Historiblogography
    Historicus
    History House
    History in Halstead
    History Mike
    History News Network
    History News Service
    History Now
    History Through Children’s Literature
    History Today Magazine Blog
    History Unfolding
    Jennie’s Rambles
    John Brown the Abolitionist
    Jon Rowe
    M-Dawg’s Blog
    Matt’s Today in History
    News From the University Press of Georgia
    Old Is the New New
    Old Virginia Blog
    Out of Battle
    Past Tyme With Good Companye
    Patahistory
    Patriots and Peoples
    Paul Lay-History Today
    Philobiblon
    Religion in American History
    Secondhand Thoughts
    Social Studies With Mr. Kannan
    Speaking of History
    Spinning Clio
    Sumir History
    The Chicago Syndicate
    The Educational Tour Marm
    The Foundation Forum
    The History Blog
    The People History
    Topics From 192 Countries
    Trials and Tribulations in Texas
    Tudor History
    Uncovered History
    Walking the Berkshires
    Women of History
    World History Blog
    World of Royalty

    Education Blogs
    A Library By Any Other Name
    A Swiftly Tilting Planet
    A Teacher’s Education
    A Tense Teacher
    A Voice From the Middle
    Aimless Miss
    Are We Doing Anything Toda?
    Around the Corner
    Assorted Stuff
    Bellringers
    Blue Bird’s Classroom
    Bookmoth
    Borderland
    Bud the Teacher
    Butterfly Angel
    California Teacher Blog
    Californiateacherguy
    Changing High Schools
    Chucheria
    Closing the Gap in NYC
    Coach Brown
    Confessions From the Couch
    Cool Cat Teacher
    D-ed Reckoning
    Dangerously Irrelevant
    Dolce Bellezza
    Dr. Homeslice
    EduBlog Insights
    Educat
    Educated Nation
    Education in Texas
    Education Matters
    Education Wonks
    Eduholic
    Eduwonk.com
    Edwize
    Edwonkette
    Florida Teacher
    Fordee Blog
    From the Paws of…
    From the Trenches of Public Ed
    Georgia Association of Educators
    Education Matters
    HappyChyck Wonders
    Head From the Start
    Her Education Blog
    Hobo Teacher
    Huffenglish
    I Thought a Think
    In the Middle
    Info Literacy Land of Confusion
    Instructivist
    Joanne Jacobs
    Jose Vilson
    Just a Substitute Teacher Blog
    Kathy Schrock’s Kaffeeklatsch
    Kontan’s Comprehensive Chaos
    Lady Strathconn’s Journal
    Larry Ferlazzo
    Leader Talk
    Learn Me Good
    Learning Now
    Matthew K. Tabor
    Matthew Needleman
    Moving at the Speed of Creativity
    Mrs. B-G’s English Blog
    Mrs. George and the ELA
    Ms. Teacher
    Ms. Whatsit
    Ms. ABC Mom
    Ms. Frizzle
    Ms. M’s Apples
    NCLB Let’s Get It Right
    Not Quite Grown Up
    NYCEducator
    Of Life, Education, E-Bay, Travel and Books
    Open Up My Head and See What’s On My Mind
    Parentalcation
    Pass-Ed
    Polski3’s View From Here
    Precise Edit Blog
    PTA: Parent, Teacher, Asshole
    Random Thoughts of a Teacher
    Ricklibrarian
    Right on the Left Coast
    Sapient Sutler
    School of Blog
    School Spirit Store
    Shrewdness of Apes
    Simply Sublime Stupidity
    So You Want to Teach?
    Sobeit
    Teacher in a Strange Land
    Teacher in Development
    Teacher Magazine Blogboard
    Ms. ABC Mom
    Teacher Magazine Blogs
    Teaching in the Inner City
    The Book Whisperer
    The Cranky Professor
    The Doc Is In
    The Dream Teacher
    The English Teacher
    The Median Sib
    The Stingy Scholar
    The View From Here
    There Is No Such Thing as a Godforsaken Town
    This Week in Education
    Thoughts Have Wings
    Thoughts on Education Policy
    Throughlines
    Today’s Homework
    Trivium Pursuit
    Two Cents Worth
    Weblogged-ed.com
    Weekly Scheiss

    Miscellaneous


    Wordless Wednesday Blogroll

    Thursday Thirteen Blogroll

    Visitors Since 2-2006: